After several discussions about HPT with peers and my instructor, as well as a helpful video from a peer, I finally feel as if I have a firm grasp of HPT and its structure, intended audience, results-oriented analysis, and eclectic approach.
Reading through Pershing, Lee, and Cheng's (2008) study interviewing several HPT experts on the current trends, strengths, weaknesses, and so forth of HPT was really helpful. The discussions and quotes provided real-life, relatable examples that further strengthened my sense of HPT. However, I did find it interesting that "HPT is basically an American field" (Pershing et al., 2008, p. 14), which makes me wonder about the trendiness of HPT and if it is really just "yet another American buzzword?" (Pershing et al., 2008, p. 9). But I do think several of the reasons mentioned for why HPT is still a relatively small field and a term only known and understood by those in the field are very accurate--I've experienced some of them myself, to include not understanding the definition or process, and my confusion with human in HPT. But part of the strengths seem to include holistic approaches drawing from many frameworks, which is a really good thing.
I tried to make some connections to the next article I read about The Emergence and Design of MOOCs by Bonk, Lee, Reeves, and Reynolds (in press). Learning more and more about MOOCs has been interesting and about a week ago, my husband told me about this online course he wanted to take through Georgetown that was free, but did cost money if he wanted a certificate of completion. He then told me there were 32,000 people registered for it and I became very excited and told him, it's a MOOC! He had no idea what I was talking about, so I went further into detail, but I only learned about MOOCs during this course and now my husband is wanting to sign up for one!
A few things though I wonder about with MOOCs, and maybe it's because of my background, but are these types of courses devaluing university courses? Is this why perhaps I haven't heard of MOOCs, because I am in an Ed.D. program and I teach pre-service teachers at a public university? Makes me wonder. Although PD-MOOCs are in my area. And I have to add, I had no idea there were different types of MOOCs either! Speaking of various MOOCs, I think I have a hard time understanding the concept of Remedial MOOCs, since typically in an educational setting, interventions are best done in small groups with individualized differentiations, which I can't see taking place in a MOOC. And as Bonk et al. (in press) discuss MOOCs are not always designed by professionals, I wonder if poor quality design is the root of low completion rates, or if maybe people's lack of investment (no valid certification, no cost, no assessment, and so forth) is contributing to their completion of their MOOC?
Bonk, C. J., Lee. M. M., Reeves, T. C., & Reynolds, T. H. (in press). The emergence and design of massive open online courses (MOOCs). In R. A. Reiser, & J. V. Demsey (Eds.), Trends and issues in instructional design and technology (4th Ed.), (pp.?). Boston, MA: Pearson.
Pershing, J. A., Lee, J., & Cheng, J. (2008). Current status, future trends, and issues in human performance technology, part 1: Influential domains, current status, and recognition of HPT. Performance Improvement, 47(1), 9-17.
Hi Rebecca,
I, too, hadn't heard the term until recently, but I have taken a MOOC before. I did a Visible Thinking course through Harvard's Project Zero and I absolutely loved it! That being said, it was encouraged that you take the class with a cohort; a group of colleagues working together in the same place. There were plenty of people on the course who didn't do it that way, but we did. I worked with a group of about 20 teachers at my school and we broke down into 5 or 6 smaller department/grade-level groups to work through the course together. I think that this is a really good model for encouraging completion - accountability and encouragement withi…
Hi Rebecca,
The questions you asked in the last paragraph are interesting! Is there a reason why you thought MOOCs might devalue university courses? I would think people seek each for different reasons and probably at different stages of professional development, but I do think though, if universities offer MOOCs (or like in Melissa's experience where private organizations partner with prestigious universities to offer MOOCs) with certifications, it might affect their formal certificate programs.
As for your question about high dropout rate in MOOCs, I haven't got a chance to really dive into related literature, but there has been quite a lot of them on understanding or promoting learner engagement in MOOCs from different aspects. When I reflected on my…
Thanks Mark for your help!
Really, HPT has been present for that long in the military? I never realized. And in the interview with Dr. Klein he kept referring to performance improvement, so now I'm wondering the connection with HPT?
Yes, I thought it was a fun coincidence and I loved that I knew what it was, whereas if he would have mentioned this over the summer, I wouldn't have! I actually shared MOOCs with a friend just yesterday and she has enrolled in 3! Might be worth pursing yourself :)
Hi Rebecca,
I also watched the video that Nelson recommended and learned a lot from it - I'm having my husband watch it too since he may be asked to revive a dying Master's program, like the speaker in the video - I think he may get something out of it too.
As for MOOCs, I did quite a few while I was out of a job during the pandemic, because I was looking to make a career pivot from International education to EdTech/Instructional Technology, and wanted to brush up since it had been 14 years since my Master's degree where I had a small concentration in Instructional Tech. I went through Future Learn, which partners with quite a fe…
Rebecca,
I am glad to hear that you have a better understanding of HPT now! I to wonder if HPT is just an American Buzz word or trend. However, it has been present in the military, at least the Coast Guard, for at least a decade, if not much longer. I think HPT, certainly hope it is, is here to stay but the speed at which the field grows, it the bigger question. It will take some time for organizations to realize the actual potential benefits of HPT.
Thank you for providing the information regarding MOOC. It is a term I had never heard of before this class and has never really interested me. I'm not sure why, maybe because…